1. “How Great Thou Art” (15 votes and 36 points)
2. “Amazing Grace” (11 votes and 24 points)
3. “Blessed Assurance” (7 votes and 14 points)
4. “It Is Well With My Soul” (5 votes and 9 points)
5. “Because He Lives” (3 votes and 8 points)
6. “Holy Holy Holy” (3 votes and 6 points)
7. “I Can Only Imagine” (3 votes and 6 points)
8. “In The Garden” (3 votes and 6 points)
9. “Silent Night” (3 votes and 4 points)
10. “Great Is Thy Faithfulness” (2 votes and 6 points)

The point system awarded 3 points for each first place vote, 2 points for each second place vote, and 1 point for each third place vote.